6

I've reviewed several posts regarding the new top bar such as:

but none of these seem to address my particular case. While working on https://askubuntu.com/, after entering the review queue, the review light went out and stayed out even though there were many incomplete reviews and I had left the review queue.

Here's the evidence:

reviewqueueunlit

closevotestoreview

Don't get me wrong, I'm sure I can adjust to the change, but I'm concerned that this bug will result in reviews going unaccomplished.

Edit: Although it currently doesn't seem to address our "office supply threat level" (quoting @Zanna comment [here],(Review queue false negatives on the new top bar) Makyen has developed a script that will customize the new top nav bar that looks like it may resolve many of the complaints regarding it in this answer to New top bar is live

Note: I haven't yet tested it as I'm still holding out hope for something that will actually provide review count.

  • 4
    the presence/non-presence of the dot seems to be random. How are we to know the office supply threat level? – Zanna Oct 11 '17 at 6:09
  • @Zanna "office supply threat level"...LOL. Pray tell what that means, ie someone is taking too many pens home? Running low on yellow sticky notes? ps the only reason I'm here is the new top bar is godawful and was curious if anyone else felt the same. – WinEunuuchs2Unix Oct 15 '17 at 22:13
-2

After you click the review icon (or visit the review queues), we don't highlight the icon for a while (I believe up to an hour) - you have noticed it and we don't want it to feel like it is nagging, in particular once you have already taken action.

  • 3
    I personally would consider differentiating between clicking on the icon and and a queue and actually reviewing a post. be that as it may, as @Zanna alluded to in this comment we can no longer see what the backlog is. I for one am perfectly capable of ignoring nagging, but it's nice to know when the grass is over a foot high and needs immediate attention if you catch my meaning. :-) – Elder Geek Oct 11 '17 at 17:07
  • 1
    I think this is actually helpful (or more helpful than red dot on if there's anything whatever available I can review, which on Ask Ubuntu will always be the case, except for about 10 seconds after I've reviewed absolutely everything), because in the absence of text, it reminds me I need to do something (buy staples? oh no, review, right) I haven't done for a while – Zanna Oct 12 '17 at 9:56
  • 2
    Can this be expanded to give (or link to) specific timings? Is it "up to an hour," and if so, what does that mean, exactly? Right now, speaking for myself but also for what I think is the tone of people's reactions: the highlighting is obscure, confusing, alienating. But this might be mitigated if, when users are confused about why it works the way it does and we check here on meta for a bug report, we quickly and easily find a clear, complete description--or a link to such a description--of what is happening. This won't make us like the top bar, but it would be helpful. At least to me. – Eliah Kagan Oct 12 '17 at 13:54
  • @EliahKagan We will get a full explanation of how the review queue indicator works up in the next week or so. There are ways that CoGro can tune the system for smaller sights to work better and we'll explain those. We are also open to making improvements. – Joe Friend Oct 12 '17 at 15:11

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .