5

It is possible for a moderator to merge a question that's closed, but not as a duplicate?

For example, this too localized question doesn't seem like a candidate for reopening, except that it seems to be a duplicate of another question and it has a good answer that would also help that question:

That might explain why it has a reopen vote.

So:

  • Can moderators merge it with that other question, even though it's not closed as a duplicate of it (or of any question). It is closed, just not as a duplicate.
  • If not, should the community reopen it ourselves so we can close it again ourselves? Or when a question is already closed, even if not as a duplicate, is it generally considered appropriate for users to message moderators in chat (or flag for moderator attention) to request merging?
  • 1
    If that's the goal, I don't see why a mod couldn't open and reclose as dupe+merge all at the same time with their powervotes :) – RobotHumans Dec 30 '12 at 15:56
  • @AbrahamVanHelpsing Yes, that's what I was thinking of as the result of flagging or messaging mods in chat. – Eliah Kagan Dec 30 '12 at 16:10
4

We can merge anything as long as one of the questions is closed. The "type" of closure makes no difference.

Just some context (that you cannot see) about this question:

  • Op asked in August '11.
  • Op flagged it in October '11 saying it had been fixed by Oneric.
  • I closed it as Too Localised because it was too-time-localised.

It's unfortunate that it still attracts people because the Op has no use for it any longer. The answer is essentially for a related but a different cause.

As for what to do next:

  • I see no value in merging. Who does it benefit? The answer it provides already exists twice on the master question. We don't need three copies of the same answer on one answer, especially if that penalises existing answers.

  • Deletion penalises the original answerererer so I'm against that.

  • Locking seems like the best solution. There is a link to the newer thread, now an explanation of what has happened. Nobody harmed.

  • Yes, locking does seem like a better approach here. Thanks! – Eliah Kagan Dec 30 '12 at 17:13
  • I read somewhere on the master meta that deletion on a closed dupe after X days doesn't hurt the answerer, I'll try to find it. – Jorge Castro Dec 30 '12 at 17:23

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .