10

If I click on the Add Another Answer button, a warning pops up:

Are you sure you want to add another answer?

You could use the edit link to refine and improve your existing answer, instead.

When should I add a second answer instead of editing the current one?

  • 1
    It depends how diffrent your answers are. If you have two answers to a question, that can be veiwed as two stand alone answers, I see no issues with it. Often in computing, there are many ways to compleat a task. If you write a second answer that expands on the first, or refrences it then that should be an edit of the first one, as it is not self contained. – Mark Kirby Aug 29 '17 at 15:46
  • 1
    @MarkKirby Unless the reason one references the other is to explain or mention that it is a separate solution. I often link to other people's answers while explaining the difference between their approach and mine, and sometimes to point out where to find information that is relevant to the question but that I consider outside the scope of my answer. These are signs that the answers are less tightly coupled, not more so, and I wouldn't hesitate to link from one of my own answers to another of my own answers on the same question for such reasons. I only infrequently double-answer, though. – Eliah Kagan Aug 29 '17 at 19:04
  • Here is an example of multiple answers to one question. – Fabby Aug 31 '17 at 8:58
11

It's up to you where exactly you draw the line for yourself and write a separate second answer instead of adding to your first one, but I can give you some questions that may help you to decide:

  • How different is your second idea from the first one?

    You may find another approach to a problem, maybe using different tools or just going another way. Evaluate how big the difference is. Are both ways similar enough to be included in the same post, or are they radically different, having nothing in common?

    For example, you have solutions to solve a task with sed, awk, bash or python. Normally I would not consider this a too big difference, but maybe your algorithms are using totally different approaches, which makes you think they can be separated.

  • How long is/are your answer(s)?

    If you already wrote a huge answer about how to solve the problem one way, and then you find another way to do it which requires a post of similar size, it might make sense to post that separately instead of overrunning the reader with an enormous wall of text, no matter how nicely formatted it might be. This might also apply if you have to include large scripts or other code snippets in each post. A rule of thumb might be that more than one or two pages on the screen (depending on your screen size; your mileage may vary) are undesirable.

  • How different is the outcome?

    Possibly the question is rather open and leaves space for interpretation, or the exact thing which is asked for is not possible and you can give a choice between two alternatives instead. If your solutions generate quite different results, it might be useful to post them separately.

  • Should they be scored independently?

    Well, of course two answers means everybody can upvote you twice, so that is good, right? Yes, but that is not my point. Do you think people would make a difference between your posts when deciding how to vote? If there is a reason for you to believe the scores of your posts will differ significantly, maybe because one of the solutions is much better, worse or maybe more controversial, then it might make sense to post two answers.

  • Is there a notable age difference / does the first post already have a notable vote score?

    In case your first post is a bit older and maybe has already reached a decent score (depending on the context, maybe more than 5 or 10 points?), it might make sense to post your second idea that you had later in a different post, if it is not really just an update to the first one. That way you make sure that the votes for post one stay for post one and don't get mixed up with people's opinion about post two.

So far my list of considerations about when to post a second answer or include multiple solutions in one. It is all quite vague and there are no hard rules, so use common sense and decide what fits best.

When in doubt, I'd recommend to stay with one longer single answer.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .