4

Regarding the main Ask Ubuntu site, there are two Meta questions here that I found that mention "time" and "duplicates":

But I couldn't find a Meta question where the same topic had been covered for Ask Ubuntu Meta questions.

The site has been around for nearly 12 years now, and community (and even individual) opinions can change during that time, sometimes quite a bit. Would it make sense to allow some older questions to be asked again for updated opinions and discussion without fear of them being closed as duplicates? I think we should always link back to the older discussion (either the OP or someone via edit), but it seems that it would be nice at times to have a "clean slate" discussion, even if the outcome ends up the same.

4
  • 2
    TBH, I think it depends. For example, this question by me was helpful to ask again - I wanted to get clarity on a policy, and the policy was updated. In contrast, this question it wouldn't be helpful to have dupes of, if there is a new argument, yes, re-asking is fine. But for support questions questions, for example, it isn't helpful.
    – cocomac
    Apr 21 at 23:52
  • 4
    I think it would be fine if it's a situation where you feel the circumstances may be different now than when the question was originally posted. IMO just link to the other question and give an explanation why you think it's good to reopen discussion rather than add to the existing one.
    – Nmath
    Apr 22 at 3:13
  • 1
    Ubuntu changes fast enough that there are really very few actual duplicate questions. People deserve fresh answers. Sending someone to a "duplicated" question from 2010 whose answers are no loner valid is doing nobody any favors. This site should help people not frustrate them. Apr 23 at 16:06
  • 3
    @C.S.Cameron this post is about questions on meta though. Not about the ones on the main site.
    – Dan
    Apr 24 at 8:15

0

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .