3

There are currently multiple tags covering Ubuntu On Windows. This proposal aims to bring them all into a single centralized (and easy to use) tag.

As such, I'd like to request that be used for all posts about the Ubuntu on Windows system, so it should be a synonym for and .

Furthermore, I propose that be the central tag for questions about the Ubuntu on Windows project, as it's memorable and short. It is also in use by other sites, so it would make sense for us to follow suit.

I am unable to request this synonym myself, as I do not have enough votes and it seems to be a controversial split.

  • 1
    Maybe take guidance from SO? – edwinksl Aug 29 '16 at 20:26
  • I agree with this. They're the same thing, and it would help unify the category if some OP only put in one or the other. – TheWanderer Aug 29 '16 at 20:38
  • 3
    Would Windows-Subsystem-for-Linux not be a better choice than both? That seems to be its official name. Here is another one to add as synonym ubuntu-on-windows askubuntu.com/questions/tagged/ubuntu-on-windows – Mark Kirby Aug 29 '16 at 20:49
  • @MarkKirby It may be its official name, but I personally still think it isn't quite as recognizable as bash-on-windows. It's pretty obvious what that means, but those who don't know (which included me until recently) what wsl or Windows-Subsystem-for-Linux might have trouble finding any tags to put in, and may end up just using windows and bash together. – TheWanderer Aug 29 '16 at 21:26
  • Is bash-on-ubuntu-on-windows-via-windows-subsystem-for-linux too long ;p – Mateo Aug 30 '16 at 0:12
  • @MarkKirby I think "Subsystem" is too old-school, too-technical and too-misleading at the same time. If you strike the word your tag becomes "Windows-for-Linux" which seems appropriate as Micro$oft has smelled the coffee and will add more than bash as it wakes up. Indeed Ubutnu could have been classified as "Windows for Linux" in a generic way. M$ wants a slice of the pie and will probably add EXT4 next week :P – WinEunuuchs2Unix Aug 30 '16 at 0:35
  • 1
    I think WSL should be the main tag, as it will probably the simple name for this system on the long run, it's the acronym Microsoft uses, and follows SO. Possible synonyms: windows-subsystem-for-linux, ubuntu-on-windows – Wiebe Tijsma Sep 8 '16 at 11:22
8

It's not "bash" on Windows. You can get dash on Windows, or zsh on windows, or Xorg on Windows. The whole "bash on windows" was more evidence to one of the three problems all programmers have: off by one errors and a less-than-passable naming sense.

Just saying "bash on Windows" opens a host of problems that we shouldn't have, like generic bash problems getting the tag because it's "on Windows", or stuff that is specific to the platform not getting the tag because it has nothing to do with "bash" or people tagging it just because.

The technology, in theory, would allow you to run any Linux binary on Windows, heck, you could just install pacman and manage your system as if it was Arch Linux... at such point, there isn't anything specific to "Ubuntu" on it, just that that's the default image you get. Forcing people that knows better, like the answerers, to follow the "wrong tag", because they know the correct terminology isn't productive in the long run. They are going to look for a Windows Subsystem for Linux tag and that's what we should deliver. Stack Overflow already figured out, Super User didn't need a discussion, they didn't create a bash-on-windows tag and I believe that's what we should follow.

BTW, there are less than 200 questions in the 3 sites combined, and we don't even have 20. Being the odd one out doesn't sit well.

  • I tried installing pacman in Ubuntu. Found really interesting result – Anwar Aug 31 '16 at 11:14

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .