4

So here is the scenario: a new item at the review queue of a new answer to an old question, about a problem occurred in an EOL version (was asked when it was not EOL) and has an accepted answer.

Searching for a hint, I stumbled upon those two questions and discussions: Should old questions be answered or commented on? and Please don't flag old questions as EOL, but could not find the precise method for this situation.

How do we treat such answers?

Also: how do we treat such answers, when the new added answer was tested / suggested on an upper version (18.04 in this case) like appeared in the given question?

screenshot of the reviewed item:

screenshot of the reviewed item

| |
9

There is nothing special about newly posted answers to questions about releases that have reached end of life (or end of standard support).

The goal of the site is to build a library of answers to questions about Ubuntu. A question that describes a problem on a particular release is not necessarily exclusive to that release. An answer that reports it was tested on a particular release is likewise not necessarily exclusive to that release. That one cannot be sure, from reading an answer, if it would work on the release mentioned in the question is not a moderation issue and is not a reason to delete a post or to recommend deletion in review. (In my opinion, it is most often not even a reason to cast a downvote.)

When a problem is exclusive to some release but an answer assumes it is not, that is relevant to the accuracy of the answer. If you know this to be the case, and especially if you can explain it, downvoting and commenting may be helpful. When you can retain the meaning and intent of an answer while clarifying or even while improving it technically, an edit is appropriate. Rarely if ever should an answer receive flags or delete votes on the grounds that it is technically inaccurate. That's what votes are for.

None of this has anything to do with whether the release originally asked about is currently supported or not.

| |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .