I have a question regarding a question which was closed as off-topic in February 2018, because it revolved around a development version of Ubuntu (18.04).

Ubuntu 18.04 has been released since, and after that point I received at least two up-votes for my answer. From this I get that this problem still persists, and - if posted now - would be a valid question.

So, off-topic questions concerning a development release can become on-topic, just by the passage of time. What are the rules here? How and under which circumstances should they be re-opened?

I think right now questions like this just stay in this dormant state, with some probably sub-optimal answer and little possibility to improve or discuss problems.

IMHO such questions can be reopened if they are about something that is reproducible in the released version. I voted to reopen the question you linked to. The fact that you got upvotes for your answer subsequent to the release suggests that the material remains useful so should probably be maintained.

Note that closed as off-topic questions with no upvotes and no upvoted or accepted answers will (thankfully) be automatically deleted by the system if they have not been recently edited. This keeps the site clear of a lot of useless things that would otherwise lie "dormant" as you mentioned. However, since a single upvote or upvoted answer will preserve any question forever even if it's closed, it is a good idea to try to clean up any closed beta-version posts that remain after release, either deleting or reopening them. A few users usually take responsibility for reviewing posts closed as off-topic for this reason around the time of a release. Usually, most of them relate to transient bugs and are dispensable, but a few are reopened. See this meta post for an example of such activity.

Here is a poorly written SEDE query I made to find questions about 18.04 posted in the first 4 months of 2018 which are closed as off topic. It is imperfect because it only searches the post body for the string 18.04, and the PostHistory table does not provide the ability to distinguish between different off-topic reasons, only between the main reasons. Still, it probably finds most of what we're talking about.

I will try to find some time to look through the 43 posts found by this query to see which should be deleted or reopened.

  • 1
    +1 on this. the question related and the re-open and the answer – Rinzwind Aug 20 at 8:08

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .