Skip to main content
minor text fixes; used tag formatting ([tag: name_of_tag]) for tag
Source Link

I've gotta say, I just looked at the related link, and I disagree with the consensus. Sure, [uninstall] is technically a more general category, but within the context of valid questions on AU, I am not so sure. Everything inside of the OS is software.

Sure, there are a lot of instances of firmware/hardware questions that are within the AU scope, but firmware/ hardwarehardware uninstall questions? I can't think of any, at least not any that are valid.

If appropriate use of a tag encourages poor questions  (i.e.g. "uninstall the internet itself?" as in one of the linked page's comments, supposedly a real example??), isn't it doing more harm than good?

I've gotta say, I just looked at the related link, and I disagree with the consensus. Sure, [uninstall] is technically a more general category, but within the context of valid questions on AU, I am not so sure. Everything inside of the OS is software.

Sure, there are a lot of instances of firmware/hardware questions that are within the AU scope, but firmware/ hardware uninstall questions? I can't think of any, at least not any that are valid.

If appropriate use of a tag encourages poor questions(i.e. "uninstall the internet itself?" as in one of the linked page's comments, supposedly a real example??), isn't it doing more harm than good?

I've gotta say, I just looked at the related link, and I disagree with the consensus. Sure, is technically a more general category, but within the context of valid questions on AU, I am not so sure. Everything inside the OS is software.

Sure, there are a lot of instances of firmware/hardware questions that are within the AU scope, but firmware/hardware uninstall questions? I can't think of any, at least not any that are valid.

If appropriate use of a tag encourages poor questions  (e.g. "uninstall the internet itself?" as in one of the linked page's comments, supposedly a real example??), isn't it doing more harm than good?

Source Link
Nate T
  • 1.5k
  • 3
  • 6

I've gotta say, I just looked at the related link, and I disagree with the consensus. Sure, [uninstall] is technically a more general category, but within the context of valid questions on AU, I am not so sure. Everything inside of the OS is software.

Sure, there are a lot of instances of firmware/hardware questions that are within the AU scope, but firmware/ hardware uninstall questions? I can't think of any, at least not any that are valid.

If appropriate use of a tag encourages poor questions(i.e. "uninstall the internet itself?" as in one of the linked page's comments, supposedly a real example??), isn't it doing more harm than good?