Skip to main content
Andrea Lazzarotto's user avatar
Andrea Lazzarotto's user avatar
Andrea Lazzarotto's user avatar
Andrea Lazzarotto
  • Member for 14 years, 4 months
  • Last seen more than 1 year ago
comment
Why does an AskUbuntu question mirror a UbuntuForums.org thread?
It should be noted that in this case both the OP and one answering user match on the two sites. :)
awarded
comment
Editor wars aside, can we use sudo nano when talking to non-experts?
I think the point is we really need to stop people recommending users to open vi or vim. There is nothing to laugh about one having to Google how to exit them, because it's a weird mess. This has been already debated in a question.
comment
Community Promotion Ads - 2017
Once you click that banner, you won't be able to exit it. :P
comment
Community Promotion Ads - 2017
Indeed, that space between computer and science would be a syntax error. Or you could turn those into quoted strings. :)
awarded
awarded
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
@Zanna no worries. I think it's difficult to come up with a general statement about any possible kind of missing goal/info in a few words. I will try to think about a specific suggestion if I can.
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
When I wrote “could serve as inspiration” I didn't mean to copy it verbatim, but just to write an explanation that makes sense for incomplete questions. It is indeed aggressive but we shall not copy it as is.
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
OK I've finally found the time to write down two alternative suggestions.
Loading…
Loading…
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
I don't share your definition. I would call both those categories "incomplete questions", but "unclear" is only one of the two. Can I actually post two different self answers here and let the community vote on those? Should I make them CW?
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
Interestingly, I just found a similar Q here, but it just asks "why don't we have this option?": meta.askubuntu.com/q/5628/271
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
@Zanna the difference is between "I don't understand what you want" and "I do understand what you want but I actually need a little detail that you didn't mention". I will try to propose a different wording then later today or tomorrow. :)
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
Broken English can lead to a point when you read a paragraphs of missing articles, verbs, no punctuation... Posts that make you think "WUT?". Again, I am not talking about typos, really.
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
@Zanna when I talk about a lack of question mark I am not talking about typos. I am talking about questions that do not contain any question. Like posts that literally say "when I boot my computer, it shows this icon". Now those are "unclear what you are asking". Not posts that ask "I have a problem with WiFi dongle model blah, the connection drops after a few minutes, my Ubuntu version is X. How do I get a stable connection?". The latter is not unclear, it is perfectly fine even if we need to ask the output of lsusb or something.
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
Well, there is no functional difference in any close reason except for duplicates. The point is not functionality but providing reasons that make sense. An unclear question is a post that either does not contain a question or one where the goal is totally not understandable.
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
Sorry guys, my previous comments with the word "motivation" should be read with the word "motive" or "reason". I can't edit them anymore... Gosh, I hate false friends! I think too much in Italian.
comment
Vote to close as "not enough information provided"?
@Zanna also, the line is not so muddled as you seem to imply. If a question is in broken English or doesn't contain any question mark then we shall close as unclear. If OP clearly stated their problem and added details, but we want the contents of a very specific log file, we shall close as "please provide more information". Clarity is a thing, completeness is another. Regarding custom close reasons: the first one "not about Ubuntu" is pretty similar to the last one "this has nothing to do with Ubuntu". But I digress.
1 2 3
4
5
15