Skip to main content
Andrea Lazzarotto's user avatar
Andrea Lazzarotto's user avatar
Andrea Lazzarotto's user avatar
Andrea Lazzarotto
  • Member for 14 years, 4 months
  • Last seen more than 1 year ago
comment
What's a good Enough answer and How
Welcome to the site! Please, do not use random text inside code blocks. :) meta.askubuntu.com/questions/15446/…
comment
Ubuntu misspellings
+1 because this is what I see everywhere! Seriously, even the English pronunciation does not end with an "o" sound... How can people write Ubunto?
comment
Suitable disclaimers?
I do the same when I talk about a program of mine, however I tend to write "I am the developer of RecuperaBit" at the beginning of my answer or before mentioning the program.
comment
Should I answer my own question when the solution is too simple?
If you really think it is too localized, you can flag it as such. :)
comment
How should I have made my answer more appealing?
@JacobVlijm oh mine, I didn't know that 1 rep users couldn't upvote. I do not remember the first site I entered here (maybe it's AU), but on all the sites I joined recently I always started with 100 rep "because we trust you on other sites of this network" hence I didn't think about troubles in upvoting.
comment
How should I have made my answer more appealing?
«I've seen "on zero" for months» Coincidentally, I recently got a badge for having many zero-votes accepted answers and I was wondering what's wrong with my answers. :D
accepted
comment
Why are software recommendations on topic?
Yes and I have upvoted your answer. Much better now. :)
comment
Why are software recommendations on topic?
I definitely agree on enforcing requirements to prevent low quality answers.
comment
Why are software recommendations on topic?
I have already stated that I don't want to argue with anyone. That is not the point of my question. Besides: your previous comment is more of an answer to my question than the answer above, because it addresses the "why". :P Your answer (without the comment) is kind of like "it is so because yes". You should consider integrating the comment in the answer.
comment
Why are software recommendations on topic?
@JacobVlijm on a more serious note, the fact that a software is an alternative to another one is sometimes source of huge debates among people. I mean, there are people who do not consider GIMP to be a Photoshop alternative, just to make an example.
comment
Why are software recommendations on topic?
@JacobVlijm ah, well if you put it that way. So a correct answer to "Is there an alternative?" would be either "yes" or "no", without actually mentioning the alternative. A bit useless IMHO, but I agree in that case it would be suitable for this site. Still a bit borderline because that was probably not the answer the OP is looking for. :D
comment
Why are software recommendations on topic?
I understand that they are considered by someone to be on topic from the fact that the flag was declined. My question is "why", as explained in the title and in the body of the question.
comment
Why are software recommendations on topic?
«if you want to argue that they shouldn't be on topic here» My question is: why are they considered on topic since they clearly violate the rules about opinion based and broad questions. I don't care about starting arguments with anyone. If I get a valid motivation on why they are considered on topic here I'll accept that answer.
comment
Why are software recommendations on topic?
@Seth, ok point taken, but still too broad, opinion-based questions for recommendations do not belong here.
comment
Why are software recommendations on topic?
I think you are missing the fact that asking for "alternatives to X" is perfectly fine on Software Recommendations, as it should be. It is not fine here and I still can get why my flag was declined.
asked
Loading…
comment
How shoud I deal with an update mixed with "thanks"?
Ok, thanks. Actually I don't think it's an answer, or let me say it differently, I don't see what it adds to my answer apart the fact that it explicitly states to press "Advanced Scan" in TestDisk. The rest looks pretty much like mine. :-)