6

I use Linux Mint 17.1 which is based on Ubuntu 14.04. I thought to ask/contribute here on Trusty issues and on the Mint forums over Mint issues. Last time I went to make a contribution a warning popped up saying that I should think carefully about posting as some of contributions had not been welcomed.

How do I find out what I did to offend?

Should I address all Ubuntu issues to the Mint forums and withdraw from this one?

||||||
  • 2
    It should be noted that this is about providing answers from a Mint user's perspective not asking questions. – Oli Mar 26 '15 at 11:00
  • 1
    Is mint a taboo - probably yes as this already is being close voted... – Wilf Mar 26 '15 at 16:49
9

Yes and no. Mint is off-topic here, no question about that. However, I have been using various flavors of Mint for the past few years and every one of the 448 answers I have posted so far was posted from a system running Linux Mint Debian Edition. I currently have almost 20k reputation so running Mint does not make me incapable of providing useful answers here. I just don't mention that I'm running a Mint flavor.

On the other hand, I tend to answer things that are about the command line and that is essentially the same across most Linuxes. If you want to answer here, you must be sure that your answer applies to Ubuntu. I actually have an Ubuntu running in a virtual machine and I use that to test my answers when dealing with things that are likely to be different on Ubuntu. These include (but are not limited to):

  1. Anything about the Unity desktop environment;
  2. Default programs;
  3. Sometimes, package names can be different;
  4. Mint comes with certain tools which, while they can be installed on Ubuntu, are not there by default. Don't assume that Ubuntu folks will have access to them.

So, in conclusion, yes you can answer questions here as long as you are sure that your answer applies to Ubuntu. If you're not sure, don't answer. Mint questions are perfectly on topic on Unix & Linux and on Super User. If you don't know whether something is applicable to Ubuntu, you might find it easier to answer questions there since those sites are not specific to any one distribution.

||||||
  • 2
    Ditto for me: work on Arch, test on Ubuntu, post. – muru Mar 27 '15 at 3:35
7

I know the help is geared towards asking questions but largely speaking, the same applies to answers. Whatever your personal views on the matter Mint isn't Ubuntu in a similar way that Ubuntu isn't Debian. This limitation may seem arbitrary from the outside but it's a founding distinction between us and other SE network sites (Unix & Linux, Super User, Server Fault, etc).

That said, looking at the things you have answered, you are picking topics that would largely apply to any version of 14.04 (official or not).

I think you're right, I think Mint probably is taboo here and that most people take a shoot-on-sight approach to it. We usually see "Mint" in a question setting and that makes us all the more ready to close/delete posts mentioning it.

So why mention Mint at all? If you can limit yourself to answering things that definitely apply to both Ubuntu and Mint, I can't see why your contributions wouldn't be welcome.

||||||
  • Are all of OP's answers deleted? – muru Mar 26 '15 at 11:10
  • 2
    Currently, yes. – Oli Mar 26 '15 at 11:26
  • 2
    I'm sorry I can't vote up your answer but, apparently, I need 15 reputations or something. It seems to me that Mint is 90%+ Ubuntu and uses the Ubuntu repositiories so I have found solutions to a lot of problems in the Ubuntu forums. I only mention Mint because the Mint updater doesn't always default to installing the latest Ubuntu updates. Am I missing something? – Gannet Mar 26 '15 at 18:43
  • @Gannet yes, Mint is very, very similar to Ubuntu but, nevertheless, it is different enough to make it off-topic here. There are issues that are Mint-specific and others that are Ubuntu-specific. Most will be equally applicable to both distributions, but if you're not sure, don't answer here. – terdon Mar 26 '15 at 18:51

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .