I recently flagged Kinect for Ubuntu users as Not Constructive, and my flag was declined. I'm wondering why — not because I care about the flag at all, but because it seems pretty clear to me that the question is at odds with the FAQ.

It was closed on Gaming before migration as off-topic, not because it isn't about games (it is) but because speculative questions are off-topic. Speculative questions are closed as Not Constructive or Too Localized on most other sites and we've only made them off-topic on Gaming because they're so common. The non-speculative portion of the question is also NC; it asks for a dump of non-specific information and it's not clear that there's a real problem to be solved.

Why does Ask Ubuntu view this question differently, so much so as to want it migrated here?

I recently flagged Kinect for Ubuntu users as Not Constructive, and my flag was declined. I'm wondering why — not because I care about the flag at all, but because it seems pretty clear to me that the question is at odds with the FAQ.

It was closed on Gaming before migration as off-topic, not because it isn't about games (it is) but because speculative questions are off-topic. Speculative questions are closed as Not Constructive or Too Localized on most other sites and we've only made them off-topic on Gaming because they're so common. The non-speculative portion of the question is also NC; it asks for a dump of non-specific information and it's not clear that there's a real problem to be solved.

Why does Ask Ubuntu view this question differently, so much so as to want it migrated here?

I recently flagged Kinect for Ubuntu users as Not Constructive, and my flag was declined. I'm wondering why — not because I care about the flag at all, but because it seems pretty clear to me that the question is at odds with the FAQ.

It was closed on Gaming before migration as off-topic, not because it isn't about games (it is) but because speculative questions are off-topic. Speculative questions are closed as Not Constructive or Too Localized on most other sites and we've only made them off-topic on Gaming because they're so common. The non-speculative portion of the question is also NC; it asks for a dump of non-specific information and it's not clear that there's a real problem to be solved.

Why does Ask Ubuntu view this question differently, so much so as to want it migrated here?

I recently flagged Kinect for Ubuntu users as Not Constructive, and my flag was declined. I'm wondering why — not because I care about the flag at all, but because it seems pretty clear to me that the question is at odds with the FAQ.

It was closed on Gaming before migration as off-topic, not because it isn't about games (it is) but because speculative questions are off-topic. Speculative questions are closed as Not Constructive or Too Localized on most other sites and we've only made them off-topic on Gaming because they're so common. The non-speculative portion of the question is also NC; it asks for a dump of non-specific information and it's not clear that there's a real problem to be solved.

Why does Ask Ubuntu view this question differently, so much so as to want it migrated here?