Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/AskUbuntu/status/751372087160410112
edited tags
Link
Braiam
  • 68.5k
  • 1
  • 24
  • 62
Made the terms of the discussion a little clearer.
Source Link
Cbhihe
  • 2.8k
  • 10
  • 6

A few seconds ago a first time user of AU askasked a question (on AU) that, which was promptly and correctly answered by @terdon. That question had an exact dupe, equally well answered by @Guss, earlier on Unix & Linux, a SE communities that has somewith some overlap with AU and a few other SE communities.

Initially I was actually real surprised that said question was not already answered on AU; on second thought it actually made sense since it already had at least one excellent answer on Unix & Linux.

It made sense, but I would not go as far as saying that before making a query on AU, one should first check whether there is an answer for it in a different SE community. Rather one should learn to post in the right community to begin with. ButRight, but sometimes it's not so easy to decide as in this case.

  • So, how should one treat a query in a community A, which was already posted in unequivocal terms on in community B, othboth on SE ?
  • Should one call forthat a dupe as ifor a "cross-dupe", without meaning that the two communities wereare one but somehow closely related ? I am not sure that sounds completely right.
  • Should flair be awarded per usual, either through upvotes or automatic increment upon acceptance of such an answer to a cross-dupe ?
  • Or should the query echoing another identical query in another community of StackExchange be treated differently in terms of flair accrual, categorisation as dupe, removal, etc.  ?

A few seconds ago a first time user of AU ask a question (on AU) that was promptly and correctly answered by @terdon. That question had an exact dupe, equally well answered by @Guss on Unix & Linux, a SE communities that has some overlap with AU and a few other SE communities.

Initially I was actually real surprised that said question was not already on AU; on second thought it actually made sense since it already had at least one excellent answer on Unix & Linux.

It made sense, but I would not go as far as saying that before making a query on AU, one should first check whether there is an answer for it in a different SE community. Rather one should learn to post in the right community to begin with. But sometimes it's not so easy to decide.

  • So, how should one treat a query in a community A, which was already posted in unequivocal terms on in community B, oth on SE ?
  • Should one call for a dupe as if the two communities were one ?
  • Should flair be awarded either through upvotes or automatic increment upon acceptance of answer ?
  • Or should the query echoing another identical query in another community of StackExchange be treated differently in terms of flair accrual, categorisation as dupe, removal, etc.?

A few seconds ago a first time user of AU asked a question (on AU), which was promptly and correctly answered by @terdon. That question had an exact dupe, equally well answered by @Guss, earlier on Unix & Linux, a SE communities with some overlap with AU and a few other SE communities.

Initially I was actually real surprised that said question was not already answered on AU; on second thought it actually made sense since it already had at least one excellent answer on Unix & Linux.

It made sense, but I would not go as far as saying that before making a query on AU, one should first check whether there is an answer for it in a different SE community. Rather one should learn to post in the right community to begin with. Right, but sometimes it's not so easy to decide as in this case.

  • So, how should one treat a query in a community A, which was already posted in unequivocal terms in community B, both on SE ?
  • Should one call that a dupe or a "cross-dupe", without meaning that the two communities are one but somehow closely related ? I am not sure that sounds completely right.
  • Should flair be awarded per usual, either through upvotes or automatic increment upon acceptance of such an answer to a cross-dupe ?
  • Or should the query echoing another identical query in another community of StackExchange be treated differently in terms of flair accrual, categorisation as dupe, removal, etc.  ?
Source Link
Cbhihe
  • 2.8k
  • 10
  • 6

"Dupes" accross StackExchange sites - How to treat them?

A few seconds ago a first time user of AU ask a question (on AU) that was promptly and correctly answered by @terdon. That question had an exact dupe, equally well answered by @Guss on Unix & Linux, a SE communities that has some overlap with AU and a few other SE communities.

Initially I was actually real surprised that said question was not already on AU; on second thought it actually made sense since it already had at least one excellent answer on Unix & Linux.

It made sense, but I would not go as far as saying that before making a query on AU, one should first check whether there is an answer for it in a different SE community. Rather one should learn to post in the right community to begin with. But sometimes it's not so easy to decide.

  • So, how should one treat a query in a community A, which was already posted in unequivocal terms on in community B, oth on SE ?
  • Should one call for a dupe as if the two communities were one ?
  • Should flair be awarded either through upvotes or automatic increment upon acceptance of answer ?
  • Or should the query echoing another identical query in another community of StackExchange be treated differently in terms of flair accrual, categorisation as dupe, removal, etc.?