Skip to main content
added 416 characters in body
Source Link
kos
  • 40.9k
  • 1
  • 23
  • 38

I'll move my proposal from the comments to an answer so that people can vote on it.

I propose to rename it to , because:

  1. Having a leading dot makes sense only when referencing desktop files by their extension; since the tag has to change but the extension won't change, there's no reason to prepend a dot to whatever nomenclature we're gonna use, since obviously it will never match the extension;extension *;
  2. "Desktop files" is how they're referenced in the Ubuntu Community Wiki. Using the same name will allow to keep consistency across the Ubuntu Community Wiki and the site.
  3. This introduces two possible choices: using the singularized or the pluralized . I'd choose the pluralized in order to be able to group toghether questions about a specific desktop file and questions about desktop files in general, which makes sense only to group toghether under a single tag.

* Before someone argues that beside this reasoning makes equal sense to : yes, mostly. But the problem is that one of the two must be preferred. Since they're both good, digressing into nitpickeries, putting the thing into what I think is the right perspective, to make a comparison, you don't say e.g. "I have a dot-mp4 file", you say "I have an mp4 file".

I'll move my proposal from the comments to an answer so that people can vote on it.

I propose to rename it to , because:

  1. Having a leading dot makes sense only when referencing desktop files by their extension; since the tag has to change but the extension won't change, there's no reason to prepend a dot to whatever nomenclature we're gonna use, since obviously it will never match the extension;
  2. "Desktop files" is how they're referenced in the Ubuntu Community Wiki. Using the same name will allow to keep consistency across the Ubuntu Community Wiki and the site.
  3. This introduces two possible choices: using the singularized or the pluralized . I'd choose the pluralized in order to be able to group toghether questions about a specific desktop file and questions about desktop files in general, which makes sense only to group toghether under a single tag.

I'll move my proposal from the comments to an answer so that people can vote on it.

I propose to rename it to , because:

  1. Having a leading dot makes sense only when referencing desktop files by their extension; since the tag has to change but the extension won't change, there's no reason to prepend a dot to whatever nomenclature we're gonna use, since obviously it will never match the extension *;
  2. "Desktop files" is how they're referenced in the Ubuntu Community Wiki. Using the same name will allow to keep consistency across the Ubuntu Community Wiki and the site.
  3. This introduces two possible choices: using the singularized or the pluralized . I'd choose the pluralized in order to be able to group toghether questions about a specific desktop file and questions about desktop files in general, which makes sense only to group toghether under a single tag.

* Before someone argues that beside this reasoning makes equal sense to : yes, mostly. But the problem is that one of the two must be preferred. Since they're both good, digressing into nitpickeries, putting the thing into what I think is the right perspective, to make a comparison, you don't say e.g. "I have a dot-mp4 file", you say "I have an mp4 file".

deleted 2 characters in body
Source Link
kos
  • 40.9k
  • 1
  • 23
  • 38

I'll move my proposal from the comments to an answer so that people can vote on it.

I propose to rename the tagit to , because:

  1. Having a leading dot makes sense only when referencing desktop files by their extension; since the tag has to change but the extension won't change, there's no reason to prepend a dot to whatever nomenclature we're gonna use, since obviously it will never match the extension;
  2. "Desktop files" is how they're referenced in the Ubuntu Community Wiki. Using the same name will allow to keep consistency across the Ubuntu Community Wiki and the site.
  3. This introduces two possible choices: using the singularized or the pluralized . I'd choose the pluralized in order to be able to group toghether questions about a specific desktop file and questions about desktop files in general, which makes sense only to group toghether under a single tag.

I'll move my proposal from the comments to an answer so that people can vote on it.

I propose to rename the tag , because:

  1. Having a leading dot makes sense only when referencing desktop files by their extension; since the tag has to change but the extension won't change, there's no reason to prepend a dot to whatever nomenclature we're gonna use, since obviously it will never match the extension;
  2. "Desktop files" is how they're referenced in the Ubuntu Community Wiki. Using the same name will allow to keep consistency across the Ubuntu Community Wiki and the site.
  3. This introduces two possible choices: using the singularized or the pluralized . I'd choose the pluralized in order to be able to group toghether questions about a specific desktop file and questions about desktop files in general, which makes sense only to group toghether under a single tag.

I'll move my proposal from the comments to an answer so that people can vote on it.

I propose to rename it to , because:

  1. Having a leading dot makes sense only when referencing desktop files by their extension; since the tag has to change but the extension won't change, there's no reason to prepend a dot to whatever nomenclature we're gonna use, since obviously it will never match the extension;
  2. "Desktop files" is how they're referenced in the Ubuntu Community Wiki. Using the same name will allow to keep consistency across the Ubuntu Community Wiki and the site.
  3. This introduces two possible choices: using the singularized or the pluralized . I'd choose the pluralized in order to be able to group toghether questions about a specific desktop file and questions about desktop files in general, which makes sense only to group toghether under a single tag.
Source Link
kos
  • 40.9k
  • 1
  • 23
  • 38

I'll move my proposal from the comments to an answer so that people can vote on it.

I propose to rename the tag , because:

  1. Having a leading dot makes sense only when referencing desktop files by their extension; since the tag has to change but the extension won't change, there's no reason to prepend a dot to whatever nomenclature we're gonna use, since obviously it will never match the extension;
  2. "Desktop files" is how they're referenced in the Ubuntu Community Wiki. Using the same name will allow to keep consistency across the Ubuntu Community Wiki and the site.
  3. This introduces two possible choices: using the singularized or the pluralized . I'd choose the pluralized in order to be able to group toghether questions about a specific desktop file and questions about desktop files in general, which makes sense only to group toghether under a single tag.