Recently there was a bug report posted as a question here. I was hoping the community could discuss whether this should be done or not.

link
feedback

3 Answers

Questions that are simply problem reports are not suitable for Ubuntu Stack Exchange.

Launchpad is the place to report bugs, its where developers are monitoring for such things, and is more suited to the problem.

If it's not very obviously a bug, though, I think we can leave it. If it's behavior which might be a bug or, say, a case of PEBKAC, err on the side of being more permissive.

link
1  
Any ideas on how to improve this? I've seen more and more questions which should be bug reports, perhaps mention it in the faq? Is there a way we can maybe add a disclaimer thing in the comment form telling people where to report bugs? – Jorge Castro Aug 23 '10 at 17:36
1  
A gentle reminder pointing people to launchpad would suffice. – Nighthawk Sep 19 '10 at 17:36
1  
I regularly do this - e.g. this question (which was later closed in this case) – fluteflute Oct 27 '10 at 7:10
feedback

I believe that Bugs are OK.

The person asking the question might not know if their problem is a bug or a problem with their setup.

The person may realize its a bug but be looking for a work around.

If someone asks a question which turns out to be a bug the correct answer is:

This is a known bug (link to bug report) you might want to try this work around (description of possible work around)

I do not believe just closing a question is helpful, it sends the wrong message to people trying out Ubuntu.

I also believe that if people run into a problems with ubuntu they should be able to find answers and solutions on this site. Just closing someones question will not do that.

link
Agreed, because most people do not know that it is a bug. So they should have at least that info from this site. – Anwar Shah May 11 at 2:16
feedback

I'm gonna say no, because bug reports are something the program's author should be looking into, and not the community at large.

link
feedback

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged